Leather Pleasure Trail

All of these Saddle models come with leathers and irons. They are also all my size, I'm just trying to decide which is better quality. The Kincade is brand new, along with everything sold with it it's a reddish brown color. The Whippy has been used only twice and very striking in color (Brown with Black Knee Rolls) and the Stubben has been used but is in alright condition and doesn't appear "too beat up" it's a regular brown color.

I am trying to decide which is a more reputable brand, better quality and will last longer. I intend to use it for showing, hunter/jumper, trails and all-around English Pleasure. If that helps at all! Thank you. Also, the Kincade is a "regular" or "standard tree", the Whippy is a "med" tree and the Stubben is a "med" tree I believe...it must fit on a Quarter Horse, Thoroughbred and Mustang all are between 15hh and 16hh, average width for their breed.